Sam threw her arms around Connor as he scooped her up. She hugged him back tightly, just enough for him to feel it, but not enough to hurt the gentle giant. When he set her down, she caught his hand and squeezed it before he wandered off. She wiped her eyes one more time on her sleeve before making for the computers.
The computer setup was on a long winding table that cut through the middle of the aisles. Given how late it had gotten, there were barely any occupied seats. She managed to find a seat away from everyone else, and away from any prying eyes that might be curious as to what she was doing.
A cannibal in Redding, California. Honestly, that shouldn’t be hard to find. Surely there hadn’t been many cannibals in Redding over the years. She typed in her keywords and was surprised when Google tried to autofill her search with “the Redding Butcher”. She kept typing, but even as she finished entering her phrase and hit search, the very first result was an article about the Redding Butcher.
Sam swallowed as she realized that this was likely what she was looking for. There was a feeling in her chest weighing her down. She didn’t want to snoop. She really didn’t. But if it helped her to understand her mate, hers, then she would do it. She would do whatever needed to be done.
She clicked on the first link and started down the horrible rabbit hole that was Lyle Hart. Every new article made Sam shiver and pause. There were long moments when she couldn’t click on the next link. On the second link were photos of Lyle Hart and Madeline Hart, and she had breathed in sharply at their faces. A half Native American woman with hair the color of Todd’s, and a young white man with his curls and his eyes. Oh. Oh, those were definitely Todd’s parents.
That made Todd Oscar Fowler actually Lyle Nicolas Hart.
No. No, Todd was Todd. There was no one else he could be other than Todd. He wasn’t Lyle Nicolas Hart anymore. He was Todd Oscar Fowler. He was her Todd. And that was what he would always be, this old name be damned.
The more she read, the sicker she felt. Twenty-six murders, and all of them fed to Madeline. Twenty-six. God, that was so many lives. But then, Todd had eaten far more people. She felt a twinge of sadness for him. A genetic curse that left him with this horrible fate. Madeline, who hadn’t ever known what she was. Madeline, whom Lyle had killed and fed to Todd when he was so young. Like Madeline, Todd was left with this need, and none of it would ever have happened if it wasn’t for this monster.
Then, then she found the interview. The horrible, horrible interview. She’d pulled out her headphones and plugged them in, listening to it. And slowly, slowly her already frowning face became horrified, and by the end, she wanted to cry.
Was this what Todd was worried about? Her, becoming like his father? Her, wanting to feed people to him, and her, falling in love with the part that ate people? Her, thinking that he was at his most beautiful when he was at his most monstrous? Her, becoming this.
God, no. She could never. The idea of this made her so sick. She couldn’t imagine ever feeding Todd people. If she had to, if he was dying and couldn’t hunt, she’d be able to stomach it, but that was an extreme, an unlikely situation. She couldn’t– she wouldn’t–
Sam felt her face getting wet. She reached up and wiped her tears on her sweater. God, this was heartbreaking. How could Todd ever expect something like this from her? Didn’t he know her? Didn’t he know her better than this? Didn’t he know she would never do something like this? That hurt. That hurt a lot. She didn’t know how to show him that she would never do that. She didn’t know how to explain without telling him that she wasn’t like that. God, it hurt her so much.
What was she supposed to do now? Knowing this was what Todd feared she’d turn into. No wonder he was afraid of them, no wonder he had been so adamant at the beginning that he wasn’t looking for a relationship. She remembered the words he had used when she had pushed for him to be with her.
“It doesn’t sound like you’re giving me a choice, Sam.”
He didn’t like to touch her. He gave her what she took, but he never gave of his own volition. He didn’t want to give of his own volition. She was taking what she wanted and Todd had never wanted this to begin with. God, what if he didn’t really want her at all? What if he had never wanted her, but he was just so scared of her strength, of her heat, that he was giving her whatever she wanted to keep himself safe?
No. No, she couldn’t think like that. If Todd didn’t want her, then he wouldn’t be doing this. He wouldn’t be risking it. He wouldn’t be fighting his monsters to be with her, he wouldn’t be worried about her becoming his father. And if he only wanted to eat her, he would have done so already. She had made herself so vulnerable to him so many times. There had been so many times they just sat on her couch together, there had been so many kisses that had left space open for him to go for her neck if he wanted to. Hell, he could have gone for it at dinner. He had started to. In that moment she thought would turn to intimacy, would turn to him saying he loved her too, he had fought back his desire to go for her throat.
Todd loved her. Even if this had started when he didn’t want it, even if she had dragged him into a relationship he wasn’t ready for or hadn’t wanted, he loved her now. She couldn’t dwell on that. She couldn’t let herself drown in it. There were more important things to deal with now.
How could she convince him, when she told him she knew, that she wasn’t like his father? How could she convince him that she loved him whole, as he was, but that that didn’t mean she loved the monster the way his father had loved his mother’s? Would he even listen, or would he run from her? God, please, don’t let him run from her. She didn’t know what she would do if he did that.
She would figure this out. She had time. She had time to think of it, to solve it. She could do it. She could love him and show him he was worth loving, her wendigo. She could give him everything and have him not be scared of her. She could convince him to give her everything and that she wasn’t scared of him. His monster didn’t scare her. He could never scare her.
God, she just wanted to go home and hold him and cry. She wanted to weave her fingers through those tight curls so like his father’s but so colored by his mother’s hair, and she wanted to tell him they would never be them. They would never be that broken. They would never be so wrong. Not when they were a they, not while he was hers, not while she was his. They were different. They were meant for one another in a way that nothing could break.
Sam was stronger than Lyle. Her mind hadn’t broken when she had found out. She’d had some bad thoughts, thoughts about offering everything she could to him, but they were just that. Thoughts. And thoughts weren’t actions, and she wasn’t in love with the part of him that was a monster. She wanted to give him that because she didn’t know how else to help him.
But she could help him now. Now that she knew, she could be there for her wendigo. He wouldn’t have to be alone, not ever again. He wouldn’t ever have to be afraid of her becoming a monster. Because that’s what Lyle was. He was a monster. And Sam was better than him. Sam was stronger than him, and she wouldn’t break under the knowledge of what Todd was. Not the way his father had.
Sam would never feed anyone to Todd.
She wiped her face clean of tears again and grabbed her headphones. She quickly cleared the browser history and stood, tucking her headphones back into her backpack. She hurried back into the rows of books until she found Connor. He was sitting in the children’s section amidst a sea of books. She sat down next to him and leaned until her head rested on his arm.
“I have found out… things. Connor, bad things.”