Sam didn’t catch up to Todd again until Wisconsin, three months later. By then, she had done so much research about him, about his family, and about what he could possibly be that her head was full to the brim.
She spent the first month going through who Todd was. From the papers she had gotten from his apartment, she had been able to run enough background checks to find the last five places he had lived, and then something interesting had popped up. She wasn’t sure if Todd knew this, but all name changes were public records unless you filed special paperwork. And even then, private name changes could be found if you had the right documents.
Todd Oscar Fowler’s original name had been Lyle Nicholas Hart. Well, she supposed it made sense as to why “Nick Oscar” hadn’t pinged too high on her vibe checker. They were technically names of his. She had found from his name a series of other information– the schools he had gone to, the churches he had attended, the foster families he had been placed with, they were all private documents, but Sam was very good at finding private documents.
What she hadn’t been expecting had been Lyle Hart and Madeline Hart, the serial killer and the apparent cannibal. The Redding Butcher, he had been called. A total of twenty-six kills, if you included his wife, Madeline. She had listened to the interview and dear god. She understood why Todd had changed his name. She wouldn’t have wanted any connection to that either. She even felt… bad about uncovering it. She really hadn’t meant to.
She spent the second month going through monsters. She had started with vampires, but from Vrykolakas to Mormos to Pacu Patis, nothing quite stuck. She had gone for werewolves next but had quickly disregarded that as well. Ghouls had been next on her list, and those had been… closer. But still, they didn’t quite fit with everything that Todd was.
It wasn’t until she found the wendigo that she knew what he was. From the raggedness of his appearance the last time they had seen each other, to the way his teeth had torn through her, to the inhuman noises he had made, to the way he handled her strength, and all the way to his ice-cold skin– Sam was pretty positive he was a wendigo. But that also meant there were other things she hadn’t seen yet. Mimicry was said to be a power that wendigos possessed. Sources were unspecific about how much mimicry they could use but were clear that at least voices were a thing. Speed and agility were common attributes alongside strength. In essence, they were meant to be the perfect hunters of humans.
With all of that in mind, and with all of the combined research she had done, when they had passed through Minnesota, Sam had visited the Ojibwe tribes there, looking into a family name of Snow Owl. The family had been very normal, at least, as far back as Sam could find without going up to the reservation. She wasn’t sure that she would be welcome, nor did she have the time. But her search did turn up a great-grandfather of Todd’s, one who had been suspected of murder, but had fucked off into the forest and wasn’t heard from again.
It seemed likely that it was a family curse, but Sam wasn’t entirely sure as to what caused it to manifest. If Lyle Hart was to be believed, it was consuming human flesh at some point in your life. And if he had really fed little Todd pieces of his mother, well. She imagined that if that hadn’t triggered it, then eating a piece of his foster sister who had committed suicide, well that definitely did. Liz had been one of the last puzzle pieces, and she imagined that had been when it really all began.
All of this was on Sam’s mind as she made her way down Jones Island in Milwaukee. She was going warehouse by warehouse, looking for her cannibal. She was wearing the suit, uncovered under her black leather jacket. She had donned the black leather pants and strapped boots as well. And then, after some hesitation and much debate, she had broken out something old from her vigilante kit. A cat skull mask adorned her face, yellow lenses hiding her eyes. But, she left her hair uncovered, just like she used to as a teenager.
She had gone out of her way to do a few things. Under the mask, and just barely visible below the teeth of it, her lips were stained black from her matte lipstick. Beneath the lenses, her eyes had liner done to look like cat eyes. None of that cat eye eyeliner that was popular, but real cat eyes, outlined with precise strokes. She might have been going by the moniker of Phoenix, but she would always be Wildcat at heart.
She was running along the rooftops of the buildings, her long red curls twisting through the air as her soft and light steps barely made a noise across the metal roofs. She was halfway down the line when she spotted something. Outside one of the more abandoned-looking warehouses, there were a few drops of something dark. She focused her eyes in, adjusting them until she could clearly see the ground as though she were standing down there, bent over it.
Blood. And it was fresh.
She lept down from the building and landed, using her heat to land as softly as possible. She checked herself over. Her clothes were in order, and after a few weaves of her fingers, her curls fell perfectly from their prison near the top of her head. Her breathing picked up a bit as she went still and silent. She touched a gloved hand to the ground, and sure enough, she felt it. Todd’s heartbeat, just inside the building.
She stood back up straight, feeling her heartbeat start to thunder. She hadn’t seen him since Zion Park. He probably thought she was dead. She touched the small bag on her shoulders that was buckled into her jacket. His knife was inside, clean, in a new sheath, and freshly sharpened. She had decided to give it back to him when she saw him again. A smile broke over her face. She held it in her hands as she remembered the look on his face as he had run away from her at the foot of the cliffside.
Sam took a deep breath and pushed the barely-closed door open. It moved softly on clean hinges, thank god. She kept her steps soft and slow, like she was sneaking up on a deer from upwind. Still, she couldn’t help the smile on her face as she moved.
There were boxes everywhere. Empty shipping crates and shipping boxes were everywhere, scattered in tall columns and piles. But between all of them, she could see a figure hunched over. Her heartbeat was in her ears as she rounded a corner, her steps as light as possible to keep from being heard. She saw him, then, for the first time in months.
He looked better than he had the last time she saw him, but not by much. He was bent over a corpse, using his hands and teeth to rip into it. She supposed that had been what the knife was for, after all, so she really wasn’t that surprised. He had cracked the body open, like a shell, and was eating it from the inside out. There was a bloody combat knife nearby, and a little ways away from the blood and viscera, just out of reach of its spread, were a mask and a coat.
She shuddered as she watched him eating what looked like the… stomach? She had never been very good at biology or anatomy in high school, but she was fairly certain it was the stomach. She was pretty sure she should have had a more violent reaction to what she was seeing. Some kind of desire for violence, maybe, the way she normally did around what she considered human predators. But Todd was just following his instincts, just doing what he needed to survive.
She couldn’t fault him for that.
With very precise footsteps, she moved into the space he was in. She kept her hands visible, her hammer holstered at her hip, the straps all still in place, so it was obvious she wasn’t going to pull it out. She swallowed hard and stepped into the moonlight that softly fell through the skylight.
“Please don’t run, Todd. You don’t need to run.”
Her voice was soft, rasping at the edges as she spoke. There was a soft and adoring smile on her face as she looked down at him where he was sitting. She slowed down, pausing just outside the blood, hands raised. She shivered again at the fact that she was so close to him again. Something in her chest loosened, as though she’d been holding some unknown tension there. She could feel her breath coming easier, could feel the harshness in her eyes softening. She absolutely melted at the sight of him, gruesome as what he was doing was.
She’d found him.